The Guardian reported that the 29 hospital trusts that NHS England publicly lists as "realising benefits" from Palantir's £330m federated data platform have said the system is not live or they are not using any of its applications, according to more than 100 freedom of information requests.[1][2] The platform, which began rolling out in April 2024, is meant to join up scattered medical records, speed up hospital discharges and improve surgery scheduling, TNW reported.[2]
The health secretary, Yvette Cooper, faces calls from MPs and campaigners to axe the contract, the Guardian reported, and the Office for Statistics Regulation said it would take the "realising benefits" claim forward under its casework function.[1] If the official count is overstated, the public case for one of the government's flagship AI systems rests on thinner evidence than NHS England has published.[1]
The answers came from more than 100 requests filed by Medact, a medical charity campaigning for Palantir to be removed from the NHS, which shared them with the Guardian; TNW said it had not independently verified the responses.[1][2] University Hospitals of North Midlands said "FDP is not live" and that it did not intend to roll it out in the future.[1]
NHS England told the Guardian that nearly 140 trusts have reported benefits from tools on the platform, and has previously said its list includes trusts using them for back-office data work rather than patient care.[1] A Palantir spokesperson said trusts using its software recorded 117,000 additional operations, but NHS England's website says it "cannot draw conclusions about cause and effect" from its before-and-after figures, TNW reported.[2]
Marc Farr, chair of the NHS Chief Data and Analytics Officers Network, told the Guardian he was concerned and that benefits must be reported "accurately, transparently and in a way that can be properly verified."[1] Louis Mosley, Palantir's UK and Europe chief executive, said ending the contract would be "putting politics above patients".[1]