The Guardian said it understands the reference came from an AI summary produced during an internet search.[1]

Most of this year's dozens of AI-related errors in court came from people without legal qualifications representing themselves, according to the Guardian, but this one came from a prosecutor acting for the state.[1] The CPS said it has a strict AI policy which limits its use so that it is not used to make legal decisions and requires human checks for accuracy, according to the Guardian.[1]

Ravinder Dhillon, a senior crown prosecutor in the CPS's rape and serious sexual offences unit, submitted a detailed reference to a case she called CPS – R v J [2024] EWCA Crim 3529, which turned out not to exist, the Guardian reported.[1] In October she admitted the citation was an error and said she had meant a real decision made 15 years earlier.[1] The high court said the fictitious reference did not affect the outcome of the boy's challenge, and Legal Futures reported that the judges went on to dismiss the application.[1][2]

The Guardian reported it is only the second known case involving the CPS, which admitted in February that one of its lawyers acting in an extradition case involving two Romanians cited nonexistent legal authorities.[1] In June 2025 the high court had urged the Bar Council and the Law Society to consider steps to curb AI hallucinations "as a matter of urgency", the Guardian reported.[1] A UK tracker of AI-related errors kept by Doughty Street Chambers barrister Matthew Lee now has 101 entries, and Matthew Lee said the cases may be the "tip of the iceberg" because many lower court decisions are never published.[1]

"This was used as a legal source to argue for the prosecution of a child and that legal source doesn’t exist: that’s a serious failure," Brian Flanagan, an associate professor of law at Maynooth University, told the Guardian.[1] A CPS spokesperson said the error was remedied and an internal review was carried out.[1]

The court did not set out how the citation got into the record or say whether it would take any action, Legal Futures reported.[2]